Jack in ‘Lord of the Flies’ and Heathcliff in ‘Wuthering Heights’ Essay

A comparative study of mariner in gentle of the locomote and Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights and the conflict they represent between civil and gibbet doings.In this essay I w unhealed be focusing on the several(prenominal)(prenominal) diverse saucys, Lord of the Flies by William Golding and Wuthering Heights by Emily Brnte. I will concentrate on goof in Lord of the Flies and his continuous conflict over attractionship on the island, and Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights and his conflict with Edgar Linton regarding Catherine Earnshaw. I will show how the two authors use different procedures to express the emotional and deportmental differences between fantastic and civilised behaviour.The two novels atomic number 18 in truth different in the delegacy in which narration, viewpoint, language and the detail of the description is use. Much of Wuthering Heights is a long flash tolerate told by Nellie doyen, the former housekeeper to Mr Lockwood a tenant at Thrushcross g align. The text is extremely descriptive only when also consists of Nellie doyens opinions and memories along with a few extracts form Catherine Earnshaws diary. The novel contains more than than(prenominal) than traditional language They both promised to grow up crude as skirt chasers, the young master being entirely negligent how they be gulld and what they did so they kept clear of him. Throughout the novel there is little talk utilize. When speech is used it consists of a variety of dialects, Standard English is used in conversations/comments by intimately of the characters. With Joseph being the acception and speaking Scottish, Maister, coom Hither vault Cathys riven Th screen off Th Helmeth uh Salvation un Heathcliffs pawsed his fit intuh t first bug out uh T Broad counseling to destruction This adds a bit of variety to the novel as it shows how different people from different parts of the country react to events.Lord of the Flies uses more advanced(a) English P iggy said no svelteg but nodded, solemnly. They continued to sit, gazing with stricken sight at the head teachers seat and the glittering lagoon. The degree is narrated using an omniscient narrator, heart and soul we can see into the characters minds and so free pass arounded us a more detailed read. The characters ar described more in depth and the surroundings i.e. the island. More adjectives argon used in the description and this gives the reader more of a feeling of being there. The island is to the highest degree seen as a character rather than just a panorama because of the amount of description used the sandy edge of the pool loomed up wish well a hill berth. The water was warmer than his blood.Heathcliff is hotshot of the main characters in Wuthering Heights. On his arrival al maven apart from Mr Earnshaw, who had brought him back home with him, promptly dis handled him. Cathy and Hindley refused for him to sleep in their room and when they learned that their p resents, which their father had brought back for them, were broken and lost Cathy responded by Grinning and spitting at the ill-judged little thing. Mrs Earnshaw wasnt impressed either and scolded her husband and enqui rubor How he could excogitate to bring that gipsy brat into the house and if he were mad?When he was first shown to the household he was described as dirty, ragged and had lightlessness hair, he was big enough to both walk and talk. When he round for the first time he repeated over and over whatsoever gibber that nobody could understand. All this suggests that maybe he was from a alien land. Nobody knows his origin as he was picked from the streets but his description suggests he is foreign youre a prince in disguise. Who knows but your father was emperor moth of China and your m different an Indian Queen. This is a comment made by Nellie Dean later in the story.However a few geezerhood afterward his arrival Heathcliff and Cathy become very thick and eventu ally Nellie Dean warmed to him. Hatred between Hindley and Heathcliff remained, this was generally due to Hindleys jealousness of the way in which his father tough Heathcliff i.e. much give out than how Hindley was treated. jackfruit tree is virtuoso of the main characters in Lord of the Flies. His background is unknown but is most probably similar to the other boys from the island, meaning he lived with his parents, he may have been sent away to school. First impressions of tar were that He was tall, thin and bony and his hair was red beneath the black gap. His subject was break quite a little and freckled, and ugly without silliness. Out of his submit stared two light blue watch he was bossy and in charge of the choir He yelled at them choir Stand still. He makes himself appear confident Merridew morose to Ralph, Arent there any grown-ups?NoMerridew sat overmatch on a trunk and looked round the circle. Then well have to look after ourselves. Jack also proved himself to be arrogant by responding I ought to be chief when a decision was made that a chief was required to decide things. Instantly he and Ralph didnt give rise on, this was mainly jealousy on Jacks behalf as Ralph was chosen as chief.Those surrounding them almost immediately disfavor both Heathcliff and Jack. They also both gain an enemy, which they have, constant conflicts with doneout the novel. This being Jack and Ralph Heathcliff and Hindley, and they both have unknown backgrounds however Jacks is slightly more certain. So in many an(prenominal) respects the boys are similar. However there are differences between the two, the main one being appearance and initially Heathcliff appears non to be bossy, later in the novel though he becomes foxy and blackmails to get what he wants.Heathcliffs appearance deteriorates as his behaviour becomes more rebellious and wild. His looks become less civilised and twist more savage and unkempt You wash your dirty face and brush your hair. Thi s is reflected in his behaviour which has become much more raw took my dingy volume by the scroop, and hurled it into the dog kennel vowing I loathed a good book, Heathcliff kicked his to the compar commensurate place. This shows how the savage behaviour of Catherine and Heathcliff has changed the surroundings by pulling other civilised things such as the bible to be more like them.Heathcliffs attitude towards Hindley becomes increasingly more rebellious. He encourages Hindley to throw things and be soaked to him so that he can use previously received beatings once against him and get Hindley into trouble with Mr Earnshaw Off, dog cried Hindley, gravid him with an iron weight used for measure potatoes and hay.Throw it he replied, standing still, and so I shall tell how you boasted that you would turn me out of doors as soon as he died and see whether he will not turn you out directly. This shows Heathcliffs sly side and hatred, so much hatred he feels that he needs Hindley to be gone completely from his life, this strains his savage uncivilised behaviour.As Jacks behaviour becomes more savage his appearance changes his hair becomes longer His sandy hair, considerably longer than it had been when they dropped in, was lighter now, and he uses war paints Jack p pass aroundted his new face. He made one cheek and one nerve socket white, then he rubbed red over the other half of his face and slashed a black bar of charcoal across from ripe(p) ear to left jaw. He uses these war paints to become masked in repulsiveness and malice, he creates a new valet de chambre and cuts out responsibilities. equivalent this he is able to cut himself off from the civilised world and commute to show his true personality, unruly and savage.The conch in the book is something that is esteem by all and represents law and order. To Jack the conch is like an adult and has the spring that he wants, he wants to be in charge and be reckon by all. Due to this there is great disruptions on the island. twain Jack and Heathcliffs appearance deteriorates as their behaviour becomes more savage, again cover a similarity between the two.Heathcliffs spirit becomes increasingly more violent. The violence he uses is not physical, its oral i.e. he makes threats and suggestive comments it is some pose that urges me to thwart my own schemes by killing him. This suggests that Hindley is testing Heathcliffs violent physical behaviour boundary and he may in accompaniment of pushed him so far that it gets broken. This is not the only time in which we see a different side to Heathcliff, it is in feature one of many but the above may be the most severe.During Heathcliff and Hindleys argument about the colts another side of Heathcliff is seen. He blackmails Hindley by threatening to tell Mr Earnshaw of the beatings he has received from him I shall tell your father of the triple thrashings youve granted me this week. This is a very devious manipulative move because he knows that Mr Earnshaw prefers him to Hindley and so thusly is likely to defend his gift of god Heathcliff.Jacks nature is violent, and the amount of violence increases as you proceed through the book. He shows how he is angry and short tempered especially at the start and specifically towards bruisergy he uses harsh terminology towards him turn out up, fatty, which are unnecessary. He continues to behave violently towards piggy hither let me go His voice rose to a shriek of apprehension as Jack snatched the glasses off his face. Jack quite obviously didnt ask piggy for the use of his glasses and instead showed rudeness, ill mannered and violent behaviour by snatching them.It is also shown how Jacks physical violence is initially kept indite up indoors him but eventually handouts itself onto piggy This from piggy and wails of agreement from some of the hunters herd Jack to violence. The bolting look came into his blue eyes. He took a step and able at last to hit someo ne stuck his fist into piggys stomach. This again shows his dislike for piggy and shows how uncivilised and savage he in fact is.Both Jack and Heathcliff act violently but they release their trespass differently, Heathcliff tends to be clever with the way in which he acts and bribes, although he suggests that he could indeed handle releasing his aggression physically he doesnt he sticks to what he knows best and shows a more ripen attitude towards it. Jack on the other hand shows a more youthful way of handling it he uses both physical and verbal violence. The way in which he uses his words to try and harm others is different, and entails no maturity at all, he uses more childish thoughtless words, he may well use physical violence because he realises that his immature way of handling words is not making much of an effect.Heathcliffs aggression becomes focused on Edgar Linton this is because Heathcliff is jealous of the relationship Edgar has with Catherine. To show Heathcliffs wildness and to develop the civilisation versus savagery theme Brnte uses a different kind of language, a more intense harsh range of vocabulary. She uses words such as with frightful vehemence to prove that Heathcliff feels authentically deeply and means what he says, she shows him to be impatient, agitated and angry stamping his pes and groaning in a sudden paroxysm.This is another example of Heathcliffs aggression being focused on Edgar Linton Cathy, this lamb of yours threatens like a cocksucker he said. It is in danger of set outting its skull against my knuckles. By god, Mr Linton, Im mortally sorry that you are not worth knocking down it shows his wildness and tells how Edgar is in for a beating. It all shows his savage behaviour and focused hatred on Edgar.Later in Lord of the Flies Jacks aggression becomes focussed on Ralph. This is a change as originally Jacks violent, savage behaviour was directed at piggy. Their conflict over leadership and the type of society they s hould have on the island has great effects on the group as a unharmed and the boys take sides. Originally Jack was jealous of Ralph as he became leader and this was what Jack wanted to be, he was mortified when Ralph was chosen as chief and this proved he was respected more and more popular than Jack. However, constant disagreements between the two meant that the group split and more sided with Jack meaning that he was now in charge.Jack was insecure and thought all would return to Ralph, whilst he controlled all he showed the most savage behaviour and made his tribe hunt Ralph down and kill him. hike Heave Heave a shrill prolonged cheer. Something boomed up on the red rock, and then the earth jumped and began to shake steadily while the noise as steadily increased. Ralph was shot into the air, thrown down, and dashed against branches. At his right hand and only a few feet away, the whole thicket bent and the grow screamed as they came out of the earth together. This was Jacks at tempt at killing Ralph, it emphasises his savage, uncivilised behaviour. Goldings description of the roots is also a description of what would of happened to Ralph had he been in the way.Both boys show jealousy and the pent up aggression they receive from this they then focus on one person in particular. This is the person, which they feel most in danger of, which threatens them the most. over again demonstrate how similar the boys are.Heathcliffs nature proves to be evil. This is shown by his bribery over the colts with Hindley You must exchange horses with me I dont like mine and if you wont I shall tell your father of the three thrashings youve given me this week, and show him my arm which is black to the shoulder. This shows just how far he would go to get his own way. He is constantly evil and constantly thinks like this, and when he throws the hot apple sauce at Edgar Linton this just emphasises the fact He seized a tureen of hot apple sauce, the first thing that came unde r his grip and dashed it full against the speakers face and neck.Brnte suggests that Heathcliff could be from the devil by selecting words such as imp of Satan to emphasise this. This is backed up by the fact that his background is unknown. His innate evil is being brought out because of his surroundings.Jack leads the hunters. On one hunt jack found himself unable to kill the pig they had captured. This is why he was so excited when the group caught another pig and managed this time to kill it gestate Weve killed a pig we stole upon them we got in a circle.Voices broke from the hunters. We got in a circleWe crept upThe pig squealed Jack then puts the pigs head on a stick the Lord of the Flies. By doing this he shows savage, evil and uncivilised behaviour. This is because in making the pigs head the Lord of the Flies he is making an idol of it this is against one of the Ten Commandments. Christianity is seen as civilisation and so he is in fact going against it and therefore bei ng uncivilised. He shows evil because by idolising the pig he is showing that he is proud of the fact that he has killed another living thing.Golding is motto that children do in fact have evil instincts inside which are brought out when they are in groups this may be because they are nerve-wracking to impress others.Both boys show evil behaviour, although Heathcliffs you seem to be able to understand more as he has a moderateness and is more of a reaction to probing from others than anything else. Jacks is a much deeper evil and he idolises the darker side of life.Heathcliffs relationship with the inseparable world is very strong. His look is that of unkept and dirty If you wash your face and brush your hair it will be all right. But you are so dirty and therefore fits in with nature because that too is rugged and dirty. At the start when he firsts arrives at the family home he speaks gibberish when it was set on its feet, it only stared round, and repeated over and over again some gibberish that nobody could understand. This emphasises the fact that he is not civilised, the homogeneous as nature isnt and therefore implying again that Heathcliff fits in with and is part of nature.Catherine Earnshaw describes him as a bleak, hilly, coal country. This emphasises how close to nature he is as this is how his closest friends describe him. The bleak, hilly description also suggests that maybe he has little going for him and that his future is not a lot to look forward to.Whenever Heathcliff runs away he runs to the moors suggesting that this is where he feels most comfortable and sees nature as a friend to himself. After Heathcliff has runaway after consultation how Catherine plans to marry Edgar there is a storm. During the storm a tree is split split a tree off this tree symbolises Heathcliff and shows him splitting with Catherine and civilisation. It again shows how he is close to nature because natural things are being used to describe him. His name Heat hcliff is a natural name and is an oxymoron. It shows a railway line heath describes a wide-open space where as cliff describes a cut off vertical edge.Golding connects jack to the natural world. He uses words such as the forest and he were very still to emphasise the fact that the two are very similar. However the connection is more of a link than a relationship. Jack uses the natural world for exploring and inquisition and it appears that he knows much about it and is very much in melodic line with it Jack seemed to know the way suggesting that he has hunted and explored a lot before. This may be because it is with the natural world that he feels comfortable and just and the fact that when he is annoyed he walks off when Ralph is chosen as chief emphasises this. If I blow the conch and they dont come back then weve had it. It shows that Jack feels capable enough to lead the hunters away from the king-size group and still be safe.Both Heathcliff and Jack are very close to natu re but Jack uses his more to help him where as Heathcliff uses his connection as a friend and to help him to calm down and forget his troubles.Heathcliff inspires very strong emotions in people of love and hate. This gives supportive and invalidating sides to his character. His feelings tend to lead to insecurity, jealousy, savage and uncivilised behaviour. Hindley and Edgar Linton epically feel hate towards Heathcliff. This is sparked off by the fact that they cant except him into their civilised world because hes from a different background. As well as the fact that Mr Earnshaw brought back Heathcliff as another son and so Hindley see him as an intruder, and was extremely jealous of the way in which his father treated him. Heathcliff was brought into extremely unfortunate circumstances.However he does have unconditional sides the fact that he cares for others so much that he would change for them, and the fact that when he is angry he does not always release it on others but i n fact will runaway to the moors to calm down he had listened till he heard Catherine say it would degrade her to marry him, and then he stayed no farther. Catherine, Nelly and Mr Earnshaw all loved Heathcliff greatly and this also suggests that in fact he must have good sides to him or elses they would not have loved him so, much.Jack also inspires strong emotions, however they are different from those of Heathcliff. Jack inspires fear and admiration. Admiration must be one of the biggest as Ralph admires him and they normally fight, argue and show constant dislike towards each other. Golding allows jack to apologise to piggy after stealing his glasses this raises admiration form the reader as well as other characters in the book.Jack is intimidating, this makes him feel like he has power over others which is what he wants however this makes people dislike him, but they continue to be him because they fear him who wants Jack for chief? with dreary obedience the choir raised(a) th eir hands. Dreary emphasises the fact that the choir dislike Jack and dont want to vote for him but do so because they fear him.Both boys shower others with strong emotions. Jack creates mainly negative feelings, or gains positive feedback from others after having previously doing something negative and then correcting it. Heathcliff creates equal positive and negative feelings.In writing this essay I have noticed many similarities in Heathcliff and Jack despite the very different context of the novels. I prefer Goldings style of writing as it gives a better description of the characters and the surroundings and more in sight into the story. However as the characters I prefer Heathcliff to Jack as the way in which he acts and responds to events are more understandable whereas Jack is full of evil.